How we grade
Plain and simple, so you can decide for yourself.
What we look at
We read the publicly listed ingredients and guaranteed analysis for each brand family, then score it on five things:
- Named protein first — "chicken" beats "meat" or "animal by-products".
- Fillers — how much of the food is cheap starch or plant protein used to raise the protein number.
- Additives — artificial colors, BHA/BHT, propylene glycol, carrageenan and similar.
- Moisture — especially for cats, who often don't drink enough.
- Price for what you get — expensive isn't automatically better.
What the grades mean
A great · B good · C okay with trade-offs · D consider a swap · F we'd switch.
What we don't do
We don't lab-test food, we don't take money from brands, and we don't earn commissions on what we recommend. A low grade doesn't mean a food is unsafe — many pets do fine on it. It means there's usually a better option for a similar price.
Sources
Ingredient definitions from AAFCO, nutrient needs from the NRC Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats (2006), FDA pet food guidance, and product labels as listed by retailers. Formulas change — always check the current bag.
Always ask your vet
This is education, not veterinary advice. If your pet has a health condition, talk to your vet before changing food.